The Average Social Security Benefit Is Not Enough For Retirement

In theory, the maximum possible Social Security benefit in 2019 for someone who retires at full retirement age is $2,861, up 2.6% YoY. However, in order to collect the maximum benefit, you would need to earn the maximum taxable amount for 35 total years.

Given the maximum taxable amount is $132,900 for 2019, this is no easy feat. According to the the U.S. Census Bureau, median household income is only about $62,000 a year and the average household income is about $11,000 higher.

Thus, instead of the max $2,861, the average Social Security benefit is roughly $1,461 a month. Receiving a total of $17,532 in Social Security benefits a year is not enough for a comfortable retirement.

Calculating The Average Retiree’s Investment Amounts

One of the criticisms from the average retiree spending post is that I didn’t include Social Security as a reason for such high spending, even though I clearly did.

Just so we’re crystal, let’s do some further back-of-the-envelope calculations to see what the average retiree has in his or her investment accounts to be able to afford the average spending when we include Social Security.

If we are to believe the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ data the average retiree spends $45,756 a year, we can estimate the average retiree needs to make $57,195 in gross income using a 20% effective tax rate (high to be conservative).

We then subtract $17,532, the average Social Security benefit, from $57,195 to get $39,663. In other words, $39,663 is the amount of gross income an average retiree must produce from his or her investments to match the BLS data. Or, $39,663 can be viewed as the annual withdrawal rate.

If we use an aggressive safe withdrawal or return rate of 5%, the average retiree with Social Security has about $793,260 in their retirement accounts ($39,663 / 5%).

If we use a historically safe withdrawal rate of 4%, the average retiree has $991,575 in investments ($39,663 / 4%).

If we use an even safer withdrawal rate of 3%, which is probably more appropriate in this low-interest rate environment, then the average retiree has $1,322,100 in investments ($39,663 / 3%).

The average retiree having $793,260 – $1,322,100 in investments is a healthy range. In other words, the average retiree who collects Social Security is also a millionaire.

This amount also explains some of the pushback in terms of why the average 401(k) is so low.

One savvy Financial Samurai commenter writes,

Americans move around a lot more from job to job these days, meaning they are creating a lot more brand new 401ks each year. Most people don’t roll their 401k balances to their new 401k when they change jobs; they instead roll them to IRAs.

Retirees with the largest balances also inevitably roll their 401ks to IRAS when they retire – meaning the average and median 401k balances will always remain skewed to the low end.

Not to mention the fact that many households have several. My husband and I have six retirement accounts between us. My Roth IRA, his Roth IRA, my 401k, his 401k, our HSA, and his old 401k which we left at a previous employer due to the fact that they charge no expense ratios on their index funds. Our total retirement savings are much higher than our average balance would imply.

Calculating Company Pension Contribution In Retirement

To be thorough, let’s also look at how pension benefits affect the investment amounts for the average retiree.

In the past, pension benefits provided income to nearly one-third of older American retirees. Today, only about 23 percent of American workers have a pension, a percentage that is in continuous decline according to the Pension Rights Center.

In 2016, the median pension for adults over 65 who worked in the private sector was worth $9,262 a year. The median federal government pension, meanwhile, was $22,172, and for state and local government pensions, it was $17,576, according to the Pension Rights Center.

For those who spent their career working at the state government level, for example, the average pension benefit is $36,131 a year, according to a 2014 report from the American Enterprise Institute.

Given about 86% of the workforce work is in the private sector, let’s assume the approximate median pension amount is $12,000.

Now let’s do the same calculations again to figure out what the average retirement account balance is for those who are able to collect both Social Security and a pension.

$57,195 (average gross retirement spending) – $17,532 (average SS benefit) – $12,000 (median pension) = $27,663. In other words, the average retiree who is able to collect both Social Security and a pension has to come up with $27,663 a year from his or her investments.

If we use an aggressive safe withdrawal or return rate of 5%, the average retiree with Social Security and a pension has about $553,260 in their retirement accounts.

If we use the historically safe withdrawal or return rate of 4%, the average retiree with Social Security and a pension has about $691,000 in their retirement accounts

If we use a 3% withdrawal or return rate, the average retiree with Social Security and a pension has about $922,000 in their retirement accounts.

Having $553,260 – $922,000 in investments after the age of 65 is still quite a healthy amount. Now, of course, this retirement amount is much higher than what other research has reported. However, if we are to do the math based on BLS research and standard retirement calculations, $553,260 – $922,000 is quite reasonable.

Despite a lot of noise about how dire the American retirement savings figures are, there is a dearth of stories about how millions of Americans are suffering in retirement every day. Why is this?

If the median retirement savings in American was really only $5,000 and the average retirement savings was really only $100,000, we’d have a humanitarian crisis!

The only logical reason to explain the difference between research figures and reality is that Americans have much more money than people think. We practice stealth wealth, especially from research institutions who ask us how much we have. We’re also resourceful and take action if money is needed.

Making Up For Social Security

Due to perennial government mismanagement, I’ve never counted on Social Security being there for me. I view the FICA tax as part of my civic contribution to help support my elders who helped develop our country into what it is today.

But whenever the topic of Social Security comes up, it is a nice reminder there’s a possibility I might get as much as $3,000+/month in “extra benefits” once I’m old enough to collect. If blessed, I’d like to use this bonus money to spoil my grandchildren at the amusement park.

The onus is on all of us to save for our own retirement through pre-tax and after-tax savings. Currently, workers under 50 can sock away up to $19,000 a year in an employer-sponsored 401(k), and $6,000 a year in an IRA. There are also catchup contributions for workers over 50.

But the easiest way to ensure you’ll have enough in retirement is to simply keep working. Yes, at the present time, you can collect Social Security benefits as early as age 62. But if you start collecting at 62, you will only get 75% of your full potential benefits.

It is only after you turn 66 or 67, depending on your birth year, that you are eligible to receive full Social Security benefits. Then, for each year after that you delay collecting Social Security benefits until age 70, you gain an 8% permanent boost that remains in effect for the rest of your life. Therefore, stop eating so much sugar and start exercising more.

You don’t necessarily have to work while you wait to earn maximum Social Security benefits. But working does do wonders for your retirement accounts because, for each additional year you work, you are not only boosting your retirement savings and Social Security benefits, you are also delaying one year of withdrawals.

View Social Security Like A Lottery Ticket

Sample Social Security Statement

The chances of you winning the lottery are slim-to-none. Therefore, as soon as you view Social Security as a lottery ticket, you’ll do better securing your own retirement future based on what you can control.

If Social Security is there to be collected, then wonderful. If not, you never counted on it in the first place.

The American government has asked me to thank you for contributing into their underfunded and mismanaged national pension system. But without our forefathers, we’d be nowhere, so pay up!

Related: How To Calculate The Value Of Your Pension

Readers, have you logged onto and checked out what your estimated Social Security benefits will be? If so, how does it compare to the average and are you excited about your benefits? What are your expected SS benefits?

The post The Average Social Security Benefit Is Not Enough For Retirement appeared first on Financial Samurai.